Baseball Toaster Western Homes
Help
Old Heroes Never Die, They Just Go to the Pegasus Galaxy
2007-05-12 03:28
by Mark T.R. Donohue

Keeping track of when Sci-Fi's "seasons" begin and end is beyond my limited intelligence, but another handful of new "Stargate Atlantis" episodes are in the process of airing after about a three-month break. Despite the fact that "Stargate SG-1" never did very much for me, I've grown to really enjoy its spinoff, which has a more talented and more diverse cast and a far more interesting (and slightly less cheesy) central race of villains. Much as how my immoderate affection for "Supernatural" probably stems in no small part from the complete lack of any other decent horror/fantasy series currently in production, "Stargate Atlantis" is an acceptable surrogate in the absence of a real "Star Trek" show these days. "Atlantis" manages to overcome the haven't-I-seen-this-somewhere-before feeling common to many of its episodes with witty writing, lovable characters, and a willingness to not to take itself too seriously it inherited from its parent series. (Which reminds me, that's why I don't find the much-adored "Battlestar Galactica" an acceptable "Trek" substitute. It's bleak as Eastern European cinema and way less funny. I know some people swear by it, but the honest truth is it bores me to tears. I can't watch shows that are completely unfunny. I have the same problem with "24.")

The best reason to watch "Stargate Atlantis" is the way it has become a post-cancellation refuge for a who's who of genre stars. For the fourth season beginning this summer, Jewel Staite from "Firefly" and Amanda Tapping from "SG-1" are joining the cast as recurring characters. They join Mitch Pileggi ("The X-Files"), Connor Trinneer ("Enterprise"), and Robert Picardo ("Star Trek: Voyager"). Colm Meaney and Robert Patrick have been on the show as well, although their characters are now demised.

But the most terrifying recurring presence in the "Atlantis" world is portrayed by inescapable sitcom vet Richard Kind, whose character Lucius returned for a second episode in the current clutch of new ones. Lucius is an incredibly obnoxious, self-obsessed lout who forces people to do his bidding (and worse, listen to his stories) by controlling their minds with pheromones. On a show where the survival of Earth is threatened at least two or three times per season (as an effect of chopping the "seasons" up into three separate two-month pods, multiple cliffhangers are required on "Atlantis") there's nothing scarier than the thought of spending the rest of one's existence condemned to listening to Kind's shrill voice.

Comments
2007-05-14 13:32:28
1.   Ali Nagib
In fairness, it's not that BSG is never funny, but rather the majority of the comedy is very dark, and a lot of that is socio-political humor that mostly works for its allegorical features. (See: all the Cardassian trial jokes in "Tribunal") But despite being a Ron Moore show, it's obviously not trying to be a Trek-style show at all, or even that funny. The fact that it took them until the third season to even do a half-way decent filler episode is plenty of evidence of that. There's no "android trying to be human," "Adam Smith meets Machiavelli bartender with funny makeup," or "deadpanning holographic doctor" to create entire humorous plots around.

But I think Moore realizes that BSG isn't going to get anywhere near the 175+ episodes that the middle 3 Trek series had, mostly because the huge cast is all so dedicated to advancing the "Intensity Always On Eleven" plot that there's not much room to expand. Once the main plots resolve themselves, the show will basically be over, probably 5-6 seasons, 90-100 episodes max.

2007-05-14 13:33:05
2.   Ali Nagib
In fairness, it's not that BSG is never funny, but rather the majority of the comedy is very dark, and a lot of that is socio-political humor that mostly works for its allegorical features. (See: all the Cardassian trial jokes in "Tribunal") But despite being a Ron Moore show, it's obviously not trying to be a Trek-style show at all, or even that funny. The fact that it took them until the third season to even do a half-way decent filler episode is plenty of evidence of that. There's no "android trying to be human," "Adam Smith meets Machiavelli bartender with funny makeup," or "deadpanning holographic doctor" to create entire humorous plots around.

But I think Moore realizes that BSG isn't going to get anywhere near the 175+ episodes that the middle 3 Trek series had, mostly because the huge cast is all so dedicated to advancing the "Intensity Always On Eleven" plot that there's not much room to expand. Once the main plots resolve themselves, the show will basically be over, probably 5-6 seasons, 90-100 episodes max.

2007-05-14 23:32:06
3.   Agronox
I think Ron Moore said that with the events of the last few episodes, BSG is moving into its last act. Ed Olmos said that the fourth season will be their last.

It's a great show, though, and I always look forward to it when it is on. The Pegasus and Exodus arcs were some of the best I've ever seen on TV.

2007-05-15 08:40:36
4.   Ali Nagib
3 - You're probably right, and I wasn't trying to predict the most likely outcome, but rather the upper bound. I certainly wouldn't be shocked if they ended after 4 seasons (especially if they end up doing more TV/DVD movies, the prequel series 'Caprica,' etc.) but I thought I'd read somewhere Moore saying that they had enough underlying story material to go for 5 or 6 seasons, which is what I based my estimate on.
2007-05-15 08:42:44
5.   Ali Nagib
3 - Also, if you really want to bug Mark, we should start having long, drawn-out discussions about BSG in the comments here. I'm up for it if you are!

Comment status: comments have been closed. Baseball Toaster is now out of business.